Thursday, June 21, 2007

AZ Legislative accomplishments this session

TAXES

  • To improve access to higher education, the Legislature created a deduction for a 529 college savings plan that allows individuals to contribute $750 - $1,500 for a married couple – for a child’s college education.
  • The Legislature accelerated the business property tax ratio reduction to reduce the inequity between commercial property and residential property. The 5 percent reduction will be accomplished in six years rather than the planned 10 years.
  • To bring the 2009 NBA All-Star game to Phoenix, the Legislature waived the sales tax on tickets sold for the game and related activities if Phoenix is selected.
  • The Legislature created a dollar-for-dollar tax credit for people to donate money to a new fund that helps the families of wounded military members.
  • The Legislature also voted to accelerate the business personal property tax reduction..

IMMIGRATION

  • The Legislature passed a meaningful employer sanctions bill that punishes businesses that knowingly hire illegal immigrants. Penalties include loss of a business license for multiple offenders, a significant deterrent.
  • Day laborers were prohibited from obstructing traffic in order to solicit employment. However, the governor vetoed the measure.
  • The Legislature gave further instruction to judges to follow the voter approval of Proposition 100, which prohibits illegal immigrants accused of serious felonies from receiving bail.
  • The Legislature set guidelines for state and local agencies to follow so illegal immigrants do not receive certain state benefits prohibited by the voters in 2004 and 2006.

EDUCATION:

  • Added about $500 million in K-12 spending, adding money for increased student enrollment and discretionary money for school districts. Of that money, $46 million is specifically set aside for teacher pay raises.
  • The Legislature expanded school choice by adding $2 million to the existing $10 million corporate tuition tax credit plan approved last year.
  • The Legislature retained the two, $2.5 million voucher programs for foster children and developmentally disabled students that were recently ruled constitutional.
  • Added about $100 million to the university system, including money to expand the Phoenix campus of the University of Arizona medical school and $1 million to expand the criminal justice program at Arizona State University West.

PUBLIC SAFETY

  • The Legislature enacted an emergency measure to prevent copper theft. The Measure mandates scrap metal dealers compile additional information from people who sell copper and requires dealers to mail a check for the scrap metal to a physical address.
  • Teen drivers face new restrictions, such as increased time behind the wheel before earning a regular driver license and a prohibition on driving between midnight and 5 a.m.
  • The Legislature cracked down on gangs by adding $2 million for additional prosecutors and for updated equipment for improved communication between law enforcement agencies.
  • Drunk drivers will have to install an interlock device on their cars after a first DUI conviction.
  • The Legislature passed a bill to prohibit sex offenders from living within 1,000 feet of a school or child care facility.
  • The penalties for engaging in child prostitution have been increased to a Class 2 felony.
  • The Legislature enacted new protections for homebuyers. Mortgage fraud, a major issue facing Arizona, is now a Class 4 felony with a first-time violator eligible for three years in prison.
  • The Legislature added 6,000 new in-state prison beds to relieve overcrowding, including 2,000 beds operated by private companies at a cheaper rate.

HEALTH

  • The Legislature appropriated $1 million to promote cord-blood donations that could be used for research for cures for a variety of diseases.
  • Continuing its commitment to fund important research and deal with diseases impacting Arizonans, the Legislature appropriated $4 million for Alzheimer’s research and $2.3 million for autism services.
  • To help eradicate a doctor shortfall, $3 million has been set aside to increase the amount of doctor residencies in state hospitals.
  • The Legislature gave the Board of Pharmacy the mandate to draw up rules to ensure pharmacists can dispense medication in time of a natural emergency or terrorist attack.
  • The Legislature passed a comprehensive air quality bill encompassing 20 new pollution fighting measures designed to reduce particulate matter emissions.

MISCELLANEOUS:

  • Clean Elections underwent changes to make it easier for both participating candidates and traditionally funded candidates. The Legislature increased the amount of money statewide candidates will receive.
  • The Legislature increased the amount of money for workers’ compensation benefits. The legislation also includes automatic increases based on the annual percentage increase in the state mean wage.
  • The Legislature extended the transportation bonds from 20 years to 30 years, freeing up about $500 million during the next three years.
  • The Legislature also set aside $62 million to build roads of regional significance.
  • The Legislature renewed the job training program, which is paid for through employer taxes, for four years.

LATEST POLL: CLINTON CAN’T COMPETE WITH GOP FRONTRUNNERS

Randy Pullen, chairman of the Arizona Republican Party was very pleased with the results of a new Los Angeles Times - Bloomberg poll showing that Rudy Giuliani, Mitt Romney, or John McCain would best Hillary Clinton in a head to head match up in the race for president.

“I think that Americans have come to see that it’s Republican ideas, leadership, and vision that provide the best opportunity to move America forward,” said Pullen. “While Hillary Clinton and her Democrat rivals continue to play the politics of personal destruction and cater to the extremist wing of the Democrat Party, it’s the Republican candidates that are actively putting forth constructive solutions to solve the problems of today and tomorrow.”

Pullen continued, “We live in a turbulent time, and we need strong vision, character, and unwavering leadership to guide our great nation through yet another crossroads of history. Hillary Clinton and the rest of the Democrats just do not have the talent, ability, or fortitude to ensure America’s prominence endures.”

For more information, please contact Brett Mecum, at 602.957.7770.

Clean Elections looking for a new attorney

Requisition: A07-39EXOSGO0155
Title: Assistant Attorney General
Position No: AAG0155AHO
Location: Phoenix Office

The Solicitor General’s Office has a full time position available in the Phoenix office. This attorney is responsible for representing the Citizens Clean Elections Commission. Responsibilities include providing legal advice to the Commission and representing the Commission in administrative hearings, litigation, and appeals. The attorney may also help with other work in the Solicitor Generals Office which includes, handling other election law and campaign finance matters, preparing and submitting pre-clearance submissions to the United States DOJ, drafting formal and informal legal opinions, reviewing proposed legislation, assisting with civil appeals and litigation, and providing independent representation legal advice to various boards and agencies.

Applicants must have a minimum of 4 years experience as an attorney. The position requires excellent research, writing and analytical skills, litigation experience, and an interest in election law. Admission to and good standing with the Arizona State Bar is required (include on resume the date(s) of admission in Arizona and any other states).

Salary is commensurate with experience. The State of Arizona offers a generous benefits package that includes vacation leave, sick leave, a top-ranked pension plan, and low cost medical, dental, and vision insurance.

All applicants under serious consideration for hire with the Attorney General’s Office are required to be fingerprinted by the Office and complete a criminal background check through State and Federal agencies. A job offer cannot be tendered until the candidate has successfully passed the initial background check.

This position will remain open until filled. First review of applications will be July 6, 2007 and further reviews will be every week thereafter, as necessary. To apply: Go to www.azstatejobs.gov. Search for Attorney General positions by entering the keyword “AAG” in the Agency Search field. Reference announcement A07-39.

Taxpayer Group Applauds Passage of Legislation to Curb City Tax Carve-Outs

The Arizona Federation of Taxpayers (AFT) today applauded the Arizona legislators who voted in favor of a measure to penalize municipalities that carve-out special sales tax abatements for politically-connected developments. The bipartisan measure, led by Sen. Ken Cheuvront (D-Phoenix) and Rep. Rick Murphy (R-Glendale), will reduce a city's state shared revenues by the amount of future handouts. The measure, which applies only to cities in Maricopa and Pinal counties, had to overcome the strong opposition of municipal lobbyists, including lobbyists paid directly or indirectly with taxpayer money.

AFT, a state chapter of the grassroots group Americans for Prosperity, also expressed thanks to taxpayer activists who sent e-mails and made phone calls in support of the measure. "People don't like corporate welfare," said AFT Executive Director Tom Jenney. "They are tired of seeing cities carve out special tax dodges for the fat cats at their expense."

The measure was passed in the wake of two especially egregious abuses committed in recent weeks. First was a decision by the Phoenix City Council to give a $100 million sales tax handout for the City North development. Second was a decision by the City of Surprise to give Westcor a $240 million sales tax rebate for the Prasada mall.

"This bill will be good for city taxpayers, which by definition means that it will be good for the cities," said AFT chairman Chad Kirkpatrick. AFT argues that the net effect of such handouts is to stick all other city taxpayers with higher tax bills, and to give cities yet another excuse to not enact across-the-board tax cuts that would benefit all city taxpayers.

AFT suggested that future legislation apply the reform to the entire state, including Pima County and the Town of Marana, whose lobbyists succeeded in carving out special exemptions from the reform, over the objections of the bill's sponsors.

To see which Arizona House members voted for the bill, click here.

To see which Arizona Senate members voted for the bill, click here


Contact: Tom Jenney, (602) 478-0146 or by e-mail, vc@aztaxpayers.org

Wednesday, June 20, 2007

This week's Tusk Times from the AZGOP

Interesting....a letter from Sen. Kyl on the Senate immigration bill is included. Looks like the state GOP and Kyl are continuing to get along, contrary to the naysayers who have been pretending that the state GOP has been suffering under Pullen and feuding with Kyl.

IN THIS WEEKS EDITION

CHAIRMAN'S MESSAGE

SIGN THE INHOFE SECURE BORDERS PETITION

A MESSAGE FROM SENATOR JON KYL

REPUBLICANS UNITE TO PREVENT DEMOCRAT BUDGET ABUSE

AZGOP - "...in the news"

QUOTE OF THE WEEK

AZGOP BIRTHDAY WISHES



CHAIRMAN'S MESSAGE

Dear Friends,

There is a new Gallup Poll out showing that the Democrat controlled Congress has an approval rating of just twenty-four percent while seventy-one percent of Americans disapprove of the way Congress is handling the job. That’s big news for Republicans here in Arizona and across the nation!

What’s more is that we see the Democrat presidential candidates running around the country, pandering to the extremist left wing of the Democrat Party. Hillary, Edwards and Obama have all moved their positions significantly to the left to appease the loony left groups like Moveon.org and Take Back America. While American voters continue to reaffirm a comfortable, conservative ideology, the Democrat presidential hopefuls seem to embrace the extremist Left.

Today, I am very happy to be a Republican and I am very happy with the crop of candidates we have running for our nation’s highest office. I am very happy with the crop of candidates that are stepping forward and saying “yes” to the challenge of retaking the 5th and 8th Congressional Districts. I am very pleased with the people stepping forward and taking the initiative to run for the state legislature, helping us to build a bigger, stronger, veto-proof, pro-family, pro-business, pro-jobs, pro-Arizona majority. And I am very pleased with the grassroots and the base of our great party. The people who volunteer their time, day in and day out, working hard to make the Republican Party, OUR Republican Party, successful.

Today, I am issuing a challenge to everyone who has stood up and declared themselves a Republican. I challenge you to become more involved in our great party and help us stave off the Democrats’ advances and work to help elect Republicans from Flagstaff to Nogales, from Show Low to Yuma, and everywhere in between. I challenge you to become a precinct committeeman. I challenge you to become a state committeeman or a party officer. I challenge you to help the party recruit more voters and raise more money. I challenge you to volunteer at state party headquarters, or your local county headquarters or to start a Republican club in your area. It doesn’t matter what you or do or how you help our party – the key is to get involved. We have a lot of work ahead and the 2008 elections are not that far off, now is the time to take action and get involved. Ask yourself, can we really afford leaving the Democrats in control of Congress for the next two years? Can we really afford four years of failed Democrat leadership in the White House? And can we allow the extremist groups like Moveon.org and Take Back America to be in the driver’s seat when it comes to making policy in this country?

When we pull together as Republicans, there is no mountain we cannot move and no ocean we cannot cross. And, of course, there is no election that we cannot win. Thank for you continued time, efforts, and support of our Republican Party and our candidates who will continue leading our great state into this still-new century. As always, it is truly an honor and privilege to serve you as state chairman.

All the best,

RANDY



SIGN THE INHOFE SECURE BORDERS PETITION!

Arizona Republicans,

As the U.S. Senate reintroduces the immigration bill that was defeated last week, Oklahoma Senator Inhofe is leading the charge to ensure that our borders are secure and no amnesty is granted to illegal immigrants. As a part of his effort to show his fellow Senators how concerned the American people are about the issue, he announced an online petition at www.SecureBordersNow.com to send a message to the Senate.

Please click here to visit Secure Borders Now and sign the petition to support Senator Inhofe and all Republicans who agree: secure the border and no amnesty.

The petition reads:

Members of the United State Senate,

I am one of the millions of Americans who believes our first priority as a nation should be to secure our borders by enforcing existing laws. Amnesty is not the solution.

I urge you to vote against the immigration reform bill currently being considered in the Senate and to oppose any future effort that undermines our national security or grants amnesty to millions of illegal immigrants.

Click here to sign the petition now and show your support. We need to gather signatures as quickly as possible before the debate begins early next week, so please pass the link along to your friends and family who agree on this important issue.

Below is the full release from Senator Inhofe's office:

INHOFE ANNOUNCES ONLINE PETITION FOR AMERICANS TO SUPPORT
BORDER SECURITY AND NO-AMNESTY IMMIGRATION REFORM

(JUNE 15, 2007) - U.S. Senator James Inhofe (R-Okla.) today announced “Secure Borders Now” (www.securebordersnow.com), a new website for Americans to urge the Senate to consider immigration reform that focuses on enforcing existing border security laws and opposition to amnesty for millions of illegal immigrants.

“Unfortunately it appears many in the Senate remain deaf to the voices of the American people, as yet another backroom deal has emerged designed to revive the fatally flawed immigration bill and its immediate path to amnesty. The ‘Secure Borders Now’ petition gives Americans an opportunity to voice their opposition. I hope my constituents and citizens from all across our country will take action, sign the petition and show how many Americans are strongly opposed to this bill.”

“Despite the promise of increased funding for border security and additional votes on a handful of amendments, the proposed legislation will continue to shortcut the current naturalization process and grant amnesty to 12 to 20 million illegal immigrants currently in our country. That is a trade off that I simply cannot support.

“The first step in any significant immigration legislation must be securing our borders and enforcing existing laws. It is unconscionable to make border security conditional on the guarantee of amnesty. Even with the promise of additional funding for border security, the Senate bill focuses far too much on controversial and irresponsible programs such as the ‘Z-visa’ (which I voted to eliminate), and far too little on ensuring that our borders are no longer porous.

“I have stated from the outset of this immigration debate that I will vehemently oppose any legislation that guarantees amnesty for illegal immigrants, unfairly burdens taxpayers or fails to secure our borders.

“It is time that we deal with real immigration reform beginning with border security. This is the best way to restore trust with the American people and facilitate future improvement of our immigration policy.”

On Tuesday, Senator Inhofe joined eight Senators in writing a letter to President Bush urging him to fulfill the border security provisions listed in the Senate immigration bill whether the legislation passes or not. Each border security trigger in the bill can be implemented under current law without any need for new legislation from Congress.

A Rasmussen Reports national phone survey conducted June 11 and 12, found that only 20 percent of voters wanted Congress to try and pass the Senate bill that failed last week. Sixty-nine percent favored an approach that focused “exclusively on securing the border and reducing illegal immigration.”

###


I am writing to follow up my recent letter and provide you with an update regarding the Senate’s work on its immigration reform bill.

On June 7, the Senate Majority Leader, Senator Harry Reid, twice moved to end debate on the bill and proceed to a vote on it. I voted against the motion both times, recognizing that a number of our conservative Senators still had amendments they wished to offer.

Senator Reid has since agreed to bring the bill back to the Senate floor in the near future. When the Senate returns to the bill, it is expected to consider more than 20 additional amendments from both Republicans and Democrats, including an amendment I am drafting with Senator Lindsey Graham to substantially strengthen enforcement capabilities.

Few issues have generated the volume of calls, letters, and faxes to Senate offices as the immigration bill. The extended time for debate, coupled with the intense scrutiny that the legislation has received from the American people and the media, has helped to identify ways that the bill could be improved. And in response to concerns that our constituents have raised, Senators have already adopted a series of amendments – and additional amendments are on track to be approved when we return to the bill.

For example, during the course of the two-week Senate debate that has already occurred, we approved amendments to:

Declare English the national language of the United States, provide that English is the default language for government communication, and stipulate that no person has a right to have the government communicate in any language other than English unless specifically stated in applicable law (adopted 64 to 35);
Eliminate Earned Income Tax Credit benefits to Y or Z visa holders, unless and until they become legal permanent residents (adopted 56 to 41);
Enhance the border security and enforcement triggers in the bill, increasing the number of Border Patrol agents from 18,000 in the base bill to 20,000, the number of vehicle barriers along the border from 200 miles to 300 miles, and the number of detention beds from 27,500 to 31,500 (adopted by voice vote);
Prohibit Social Security benefits based on earnings from illegal employment (adopted by voice vote);
Clarify that the revocation of an alien’s visa or other documents is not subject to judicial review (adopted by unanimous consent);
Provide minimum sentences for aliens who reenter the United States after removal (adopted by unanimous consent); and
Express the sense of the Senate that undocumented immigrants receiving legal status must pay back taxes (adopted by unanimous consent).
Additional amendments are on track to be approved:

Many people have rightly criticized a provision of the bill requiring that a background check be completed within 24 hours for those seeking probationary status, a requirement that would be difficult, if not impossible, to meet. I anticipate that an amendment will be adopted when we return to the bill to eliminate the 24-hour requirement and ensure that probationary status is not granted until a background check is completed, no matter how long that takes.
To counter concerns that visitors will continue to overstay their visas, we’ll adopt an amendment to increase mandatory minimum sentences for people who do so.
And, perhaps most importantly, in response to concerns that the President and Congress will not fulfill all of the promises of improved enforcement made in the bill, the bill will include an advance appropriation of $4.4 billion – an unprecedented step – to fund the next five years’ worth of critical border enforcement efforts.
Besides fighting to ensure that the resources are made available to enforce the law, I intend to pursue vigorous oversight to hold this administration’s (and the next administration’s) feet to the fire so that promises made are promises kept.

As I said in my previous correspondence, the reform bill is not what I would have written if I could have written it on my own, but it represents the first strong, bipartisan consensus for enforcing our laws and securing the border in a long time. Much of the existing law, enacted in 1986, is unenforceable – especially the requirement that employers verify eligibility for employment. To cite just one problem, employers have to rely on documents that are easily counterfeited. So it is not enough just to say “enforce the law” – existing law needs to be strengthened.

While I agree with many who say we should focus first on enforcement, the reality is that Republicans no longer control the House or Senate, and the chances that Democrats would allow an enforcement-only bill to be considered, let alone pass, are slim to none.

Some suggest delaying action altogether so that we can take our case to the American people and let them decide at the next election. But immigration won’t be the only issue voters consider, and it is certainly possible that Democrats will not only retain control of the House and Senate, but win the White House as well. And you can bet that the conservative gains we’ve made in the current reform bill – significant new resources to secure the border and enforce the law in the interior, including at the workplace; the use of triggers to require that these enforcement resources are in place before other parts of the bill are implemented; an end to chain migration; and a temporary worker program that is truly temporary – would be lost with Democrats dominating Congress and the presidency.

Still others argue that no bill is better than this immigration bill. That’s a hard argument to make when illegal immigrants (over 10 percent criminals) continue to pour across our borders, burdening our schools, hospitals, and judicial systems, and crime and violence are rampant. Moreover, doing nothing really equates to silent amnesty for those who are here illegally.

Arizona is suffering because of illegal immigration. Every day that we delay action, an estimated 5,000 new illegal immigrants cross over our borders. Every day the situation continues to get worse, and something has to be done about it. Doing nothing is not an option. Existing law is not enforceable (employee work eligibility requirements, as I said, are a joke) – so, only by passing a new law that is enforceable can we end illegal immigration.

For further information, you may wish to review an op-ed I wrote for the Arizona Republic further explaining the status of the bill, a column from the Weekly Standard, as well as a list of 10 key reforms included in the legislation. There is no political benefit to what I’ve tried to accomplish, only political criticism. There is only one reason to do what I am trying to do here, and that is to solve a very serious problem – with serious repercussions for Arizona – in a way that helps restore confidence in our government and respect for the rule of law.

Please let me know if you have any comments or questions, or if you would like further updates on the status of the reform bill. Your support is important to me, and I will continue to work hard to earn it.

Sincerely,

JON KYL



REPUBLICANS UNITE TO PREVENT DEMOCRAT BUDGET ABUSE


It’s “spending time” in Washington again, and that means if one of two things: either you’re sweating through another humid mid-Atlantic June, or you’re already knee-deep in so much pork that an average appropriations lobbyist hasn’t seen his feet for weeks now.

It has been argued that one of the reasons Republicans lost control of Congress is that their last few years in the majority they had taken to spending like a bunch of (to quote our own Senator McCain) drunken sailors (no offense to any drunken sailors who might be reading this). As Gary Bauer points out in his recent “American Values” fax, conservatives are actually fighting for lower taxes and less spending again and managed to temporarily shut down the US House last week to prevent the liberal Democrats led by Nancy Pelosi and our own Gabby Giffords (we’re not kidding!) among others, attempted to change the rules governing how pork-barrel earmark spending projects may be passed into law.

Not to be outdone by the Republicans in Congress who can sense a floundering Democrat majority from miles away, President Bush and the White House have issued no fewer than NINE VETO THREATS over pork-laden spending bills this year – to keep Democrats from busting the bank and forcing liberal tax hikes from becoming necessary. Sure, we’ve said if before, but we know Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid aren’t listening... but still, we’ll say it again: YOU CAN’T TAX AND SPEND YOUR WAY TO PROSPERITY!

So, we’ve got President Bush, we’ve got Republican Leader John Boehner, and we’ve got four strong votes in the House with Congressmen Flake, Franks, Shadegg and Renzi, not to mention Senators Kyl and McCain to stand in the way of the Democrats’ dirty budget-busting tricks.

The moment the Democrats stopped surrendering overseas to terrorists and thugs, they started pandering to the special interests and corrupt campaign fat cats who bankroll their politics of personal destruction here at home. You think they would have learned something about being in the minority for more than a decade – but clearly all they learned was how to get to the minority, because that’s where this spending spree is going to get them.

Friends, call (202) 224-3121 and tell Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid to stop wasting taxpayer money on hidden, secret pork-barrel projects and to pass a balanced budget like Republicans did not that long ago. And call (202) 224-3121 and thank our Arizona Republican congressional delegation for fighting to protect our tax dollars from being misspent by the Democrats in this budget!



PULLEN TO REID: IT'S TIME FOR YOU TO GO


QUOTE OF THE WEEK

“Poverty is uncomfortable; but nine times out of ten the best thing that can happen to a young man is to be tossed overboard and compelled to sink or swim.”
- James Garfield


AZGOP BIRTHDAY WISHES

A Very Happy 49th Birthday goes out tour esteemed AZGOP State Treasurer Timothy Lee. Happy Birthday Timothy, may you have many more.

Tuesday, June 19, 2007

Zillow cleared to operate in Arizona

Zillow.com, the popular web site that provides people with estimates of home property values, gained legal protection in Arizona with passage of SB1291.

The bill, which passed the House Tuesday with an emergency clause on it, protects Zillow and other online sites that provide estimates of property values but are not appraisals. The bill became necessary when the Arizona Board of Appraisal threatened to shut down Zillow. The bill goes to the governor for her signature.

“Government should not be trying to deny its citizens access to information,” said. Rep. Michele Reagan, R-Scottsdale and chairwoman of the House Commerce Committee.

The Arizona Board of Appraisal sent two cease and desist letters ordering Zillow.com to stop offering its free service in the state. The board is also considering suing the Seattle-based company despite its wide popularity in Arizona and around the nation. In addition, the board asked the Arizona attorney general to prosecute Zillow.com for offering “zestimates.”

“The Board of Appraisal tried to stifle access but I am glad the Legislature stepped up to support the free market,” said Reagan, the chief sponsor of the measure.

For further information contact:

Barrett Marson, Director of Communications

Arizona House of Representatives

Office: (602) 926-3233, e-mail: bmarson@azleg.gov


Mitt Romney available for media June 20

On Wednesday, June 20, Governor Mitt Romney will hold a media availability in Gilbert, Arizona. Details of the media availability are as follows:

Wednesday, June 20, 2007:

5:05 p.m. - 5:25 p.m.

Governor Romney Holds a Media Availability

Villa Siena

890 West Elliott Rd.

Gilbert, Arizona

Notes: A mult-box will be available.

Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio will introduce Governor Romney. State Sen. Chuck Gray, State Reps. Rich Crandall and Mark Anderson will also attend the media availability.


Romney Press Shop

phone: 857-288-6390

Municipal Tax Incentives Bill Must Pass

Legislation would hold city government accountable

The Arizona Free Enterprise Club, a pro-growth advocacy group, today called on the passage of HB2515 or SB1350, spearheaded by Sen. Ken Cheuvront (D, Phoenix ) and Rep. Rick Murphy (R-Glendale). The bill would force cities to pay for tax incentives they offer to private retail businesses.

“If local governments want to offer tax breaks to private retailers, then they can pay for them.” said Steve Voeller, president of the Club.

Neither bill would prohibit cities from offering incentives, but would rather deduct the amount of the incentive from the offering city’s state shared revenue.

“I’d be willing to bet that local officials will think twice before offering tax incentives if they know their city’s taxpayers are on the hook for the bill.”

“These targeted tax giveaways are not only a waste of money, but it’s puts businesses that don’t receive special breaks at a competitive disadvantage.”

The bills were stalled for the past couple of months, but have recently taken on new life as state lawmakers do not want to end the session failing to act on this important legislation.

Two recent tax giveaways agreements are particularly egregious and caught lawmakers’ attention. The city of Surprise recently announced a $240 million sales tax rebate to Westcor, and the city of Phoenix agreed to a $100 million rebate to CityNorth. Phoenix is also behind an effort to raise the city’s sales tax.

CONTACT: Steve Voeller: (602) 346-5061

Goldwater Institute Announces $1 Million Gift to Launch Litigation Center

Contribution will establish Scharf-Norton Center for Constitutional Litigation

The Goldwater Institute announced today that Arizona businessmen R. Evan Scharf and John R. Norton III have arranged for a $1 million challenge grant to establish and fund the Goldwater Institute Scharf-Norton Center for Constitutional Litigation.

“The Goldwater Institute provides constitutionally sound policy research and recommendations for Arizona lawmakers,” Goldwater President Darcy Olsen said today, “but when government oversteps the boundaries of the constitution, sometimes what you need is a good lawyer.” The Scharf-Norton Center will litigate issues related to school choice, private property rights and government reform. The Center’s first case will be announced later this summer.

R. Evan Scharf is a private investor and philanthropist. Born and raised in New York City, Mr. Scharf earned his undergraduate degree at Trinity College and attended Harvard Law School before earning his MBA from the Harvard Business School. He then spent ten years on Wall Street, first as a financial analyst with Loeb, Rhoades, and later as a general partner at Wood, Struthers and Winthrop. Since moving to Arizona in 1973, Scharf has served as CFO of a real estate and cattle company, senior vice president-investments at Paine Webber, and co-managing partner of the Fountainhead Financial Group. Mr. Scharf is a former member of the Goldwater Institute board of directors. He lives with his wife Sue Chasin Scharf in Flagstaff and Scottsdale.

John R. Norton III, is Chairman of the J.R. Norton Company, an agricultural business he founded in 1955. A third generation Arizonan, Mr. Norton was born in Phoenix and graduated from the University of Arizona before serving as a First Lieutenant in the United States Air Force. Mr. Norton also served as Deputy Secretary of the U.S. Department of Agriculture during the Reagan Administration, and has been a director of several companies including America West Airlines, Arizona Public Service, the Apollo Group, and Shamrock Foods. Mr. Norton is a member of the Goldwater Institute board of directors and a former chairman. He and his wife Doris reside in Phoenix.

The Scharf-Norton Center will be directed by Clint Bolick, who is best known for leading the nationwide litigation effort culminating in Zelman v. Simmons-Harris, the landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision upholding school vouchers. Mr. Bolick also successfully argued the 2005 U.S. Supreme Court case that struck down regulatory roadblocks to the direct interstate shipment of wine, and was lead attorney in the Bailey’s Brake Service case reinforcing Arizona’s constitutional protection against eminent domain abuse.

The Scharf-Norton Center has also received significant support from the Challenge Foundation; additional fundraising efforts will commence this summer.


Jess Yescalis
Director of Development
Goldwater Institute
602-400-5683 (c)
jyescalis@goldwaterinstitute.org